We install and service both, so we have no dog in this fight. Here is how they actually compare in a typical Oakville home.
Up-front cost
- Gas insert installed: $4,500–$8,500 including venting and gas line
- Wood insert installed: $3,800–$7,000
- Electric unit: $1,200–$3,500
Running cost and heat
A modern direct-vent gas insert runs 70–80% efficient and costs roughly $0.90–$1.40 per hour at current Ontario rates. A good wood insert can exceed that efficiency and heats a larger area, but only if you burn properly seasoned hardwood — and you have to store, split and carry it.
Maintenance reality
- Gas: one annual service, glass cleaning, occasional thermocouple or valve work
- Wood: annual sweep, ash removal after most burns, gasket and firebrick replacement every few years
Resale and lifestyle
In Oakville, buyers overwhelmingly prefer gas for convenience, especially in Glen Abbey and Joshua Creek. Wood retains a strong following in older Bronte and Old Oakville homes where the fireplace is a feature rather than a heat source.
Our recommendation
If you want heat on demand with no effort, choose gas. If you value the fire itself and do not mind the work, wood is still unbeatable. If you rarely use it and want ambience, electric is the sensible budget answer.
FAQ